Orange County Breeze
News of Northwest Orange County, CA




Editorial

April 10, 2013
 

Proposed fee to search court records hits poor litigants hardest

More articles by »
Written by: courtesy
Tags: , , ,
Printer-friendly version of this post Printer-friendly version of this post
Cypress, Board of Equalization, Michelle Steel, Dr. Prakash Narain

The following guest editorial was submitted by Michelle Steel, vice chairwoman of the California State Board of Equalization.

Transparency is a bulwark of liberty. The right of the people to search court records is fundamental to a free society. Yet a new public records tax, proposed by Gov. Jerry Brown and currently being debated in the Legislature, would create for many Californians cost-prohibitive roadblocks for public access to court documents.

The proposal would create a new $10 fee for each search request to search a name or file in court. It would also increase the cost of making copies of court documents from 50 cents to $1.

This fee, tantamount to a public records tax, represents a significant change from current law, where a $15 fee is charged if it takes court staff longer than 10 minutes to find a document. Under the new rules, the public would be required to pay $10 upfront just for asking for a court file.

The rationale for this increase is that court budgets have been slashed in recent years. The plan was actually hatched by judges and court officials in December, according to the San Francisco Chronicle.

With $1.2 billion in cuts to courts over four years, it is no wonder that court officials are looking for new funding. Try calling your local courthouse to make an appointment, or ask a question. The wait times can be an outrage. There comes a point when the delays caused by these cuts verge on a violation of our constitutional rights. Something must be done.

But the solution is not to increase costs to the public and decrease access to court documents. One reason court budgets have been cut by more than $1 billion is because of the pain politicians know it will cause the public when they face a judicial backlog.

To preserve pet projects and increase state revenue to fund new spending, politicians strike at necessary government functions, instead of creating efficiencies or cutting boondoggle programs, such as high-speed rail. Then they demand more money in order to keep the courthouse doors open.

The price increase will disproportionately affect the poorest Californians, many of whom cannot afford $10 per document or $1 per copy when doing the research on their cases. It also would undercut the mission of the news media by making it pricier to search court documents to publicize judicial decisions.

In a weak attempt at fairness, the proposal provides a fee exemption for individuals requesting a single search of their own case records. That will be little consolation to Californians researching other cases in order to prepare their own, and it won’t help the interests of the general public in knowing what is happening in California courtrooms.

Transparency is essential to an ordered and functioning court system in a free society. Limiting access to court records makes it more difficult to prepare a case, or to monitor the decision-making process of our judicial branch. Gov. Brown’s public-records fee boost will be a step backward on California’s path to increased government transparency, and it will hurt those who could gain the most from ease of access to records but who can least afford to pay for it.

Featured photo

Michelle Steel is shown with then-Cypress Mayor Pro Tem Prakash Narain, M.D., in a courtesy photo from the City of Cypress. Ms. Steel visited the city in August 2012.

More about Orange County Breeze

Did you know that we have a monthly print edition?

We do!

We also have digital version of our print edition online.

To receive a daily email summary of the news, subscribe to our free daily feed!

You can also like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter!

Enhanced by Zemanta


About the Author

courtesy
This author is used when OC Breeze publishes news releases from other organizations.



Subscribe to our daily morning email news update!
 
 

 
power-outages

Unplanned power outages in Orange County as of Monday, July 28

As of this morning, Southern California Edison is working on the following power outages: Yorba Linda, Joshua Dr.: Started at 9:13 a.m. on July 27. The cause was extreme heat. Edison crews are working to restore power to 7 cust...
by cehwiedel
0

 
 
weather icon, partly cloudy

Today’s weather forecast for Monday, July 28

Today’s local weather: Patchy fog before 11am. Otherwise, mostly sunny, with a high near 87. Light south wind becoming southwest 5 to 10 mph in the afternoon.
by courtesy
0

 
 
Shown left to right at the opening ceremony of the 2014 Cypress Community Festival are Mayor Leroy Mills, Mayor Pro Tem Rob Johnson, Assemblywoman Sharon Quirk-Silva, and Councilwoman Mariellen Yarc. Photo by C.E.H. Wiedel.

Local elected officials help to open Cypress Festival

As is traditional, the opening ceremony for the Cypress Community Festival was short, to allow the real entertainers to get a running start on the day. The ceremony was delayed slightly because the singer for the national anthe...
by shelley
0

 

Subscribe to our daily overnight news summary!

 
Seal Beach Police Chief Joe Stilonovich with members of the board of the newly launched Seal Beach Police Foundation. Photo by C.E.H. Wiedel.

Seal Beach Police Foundation launches

For several years, a slowly simmering pot of community service and a heart of need has been beating. As of today, Monday, July 21, the collaboration and pre-work has been done to announce the newly formed Seal Beach Police Foun...
by courtesy
0

 
 
EWTN-logo-square

Eternal Word Television Network to open facility on Christ Cathedral campus

EWTN Global Catholic Network has begun construction of its first West Coast television news and broadcast facility located within the iconic Tower of Hope on the Christ Cathedral campus. EWTN hopes to begin broadcasting news, t...
by courtesy
0